I went ahead and bought the one with the lid and got it yesterday (Amazon Prime). Took about 5 minutes to install. They supply a little plastic pry tool and I just used it and another plastic tool that I had to pry the old one out from the back. I used a little bit of blue tape along the trim to protect it (just in case) from scratching. The old one eventually came out without too much fuss.
The new one just snaps back in - I pushed in the front edge first and then snapped down the back edge. Sort of in reverse of how the old one came out.
It matches the color and texture pretty well but not a perfect match. I doubt anyone would ever notice and I certainly won't. You will need to maintain some fingernail in order to open the lid easily or I guess you might be able to put a small dot of foam under it to keep it "proud" of the edge a bit to make it easier to open.
Not a lot of storage but it will hold some coin and breath mints.
Disappointed that it didn't come with the condom they showed in the picture but I guess you just can't rely on advertisements any more.
