I cant answer with personal experience since I've only driven E92 and not F8x, but here is some useful information you might find helpful:
http://www.whyhighend.com/floating-v...-calipers.html
http://www.neo-motorsport.com/articles/4
Seems that floating calipers are cheaper, lighter, and last longer (because had one set of pistons on the front vs a fixed has two sets of pistons on both sides of the disc), but could have sticking problems if the caliper does not slide back to its original position. Fixed has more even stopping power but it is heavier and can be costly to maintain/replace. Hope this helps.